@jim_in_pgh
While I have not used Polyurethane (PU) in CO2 guns, I use it in my ORing piston seals for cases where the power is moderate to low (mainly old Match rifles).
In higher power applications I use H-NBR because it has better resistance to "setting".
Now, this table:
https://www.apachepipe.com/assets/chemical-resistance-table.pdf
Says that PU has excellent resistance to Carbon Dioxide, experiencing "little to no effect" from exposure to CO2.
Now, my experience with Pistols, (the SSP's like the V-10 and the FAS 6004) tells me that Quad rings are better suited to the low pressures in those systems.
So, I would buy the PU Orings if a few dollars made the difference, whatever you decide shipping is almost going to cost more than the Orings themselves.
Now, for the price of a first class stamp, I can send you two 009 Sh 90 A Orings and two M2X5 Sh 70 A Orings.
😉
Why don't we do this:
You buy the PU Orings and I will send you the Sh 90 A and the Sh 70 A, you can then test all.
The only requirement is that you keep track of the endurance of them and post to this forum when you have some experience.
Huh?
What say Ye?
Keep well and shoot straight!
HM